Amber Heard says Johnny Depp’s verdict ought to be overturned on account of complicated juror info – Deadline

A month after Johnny Depp gained his multi-million greenback libel lawsuit in opposition to Amber Heard, ex-Pirates of the Caribbean Now the star is formally dealing with the primary try to crush his authorized victory with a pointy one-two.

“For all the explanations set forth above, and for the explanations set forth within the file of the listening to and in court docket, within the Motions to Restrict Legal responsibility and Motions to Strike, Ms Hurd respectfully requests this court docket to put aside the jury’s verdict in favor in opposition to Mr. Depp and in opposition to Ms. Heard as a complete, dismiss the criticism, or, alternatively, order a brand new trial,” reads the much-anticipated memorandum filed on July 1 within the District Courtroom of Virginia Aquaman Star Legal professionals.

Hurd has lengthy claimed that she was subjected to extreme home violence by Depp. In 2020, she advised a British court docket and an American court docket this 12 months that she had additionally been sexually assaulted by Depp on a number of events.

Nearly from the June 1 verdict of over $10 million delivered by a big majority in favor of Depp absent from Fairfax, Choose Penny Azkarat, the Virginia courtroom, Heard’s protection led by Elian Bredehoft, and the $100 million counterclaim crew have made it clear that they’re going to enchantment. Sharp Choose Azkarate’s demand on the June 24 closing ruling listening to that Hurd should submit an $8.35 million bail to start out any enchantment appears to solely shut one entry level for now as one other opens up.

Nonetheless, what’s stunning is the directed jury uppercut that Heard unleashed. Not like the just about formulaic request that the decision be severely curtailed primarily based on precedent and course of, allegations of sloppy jury testing may be explosive.

“RS. Heard additionally asks this court docket to research potential juror misconduct and take acceptable motion warranted by the findings of the investigation,” the 43-page memo reads. In a case filled with pretzel twists since Depp first sued his ex spouse and Rum diary $50 million co-star in early 2019 in comparison with late 2018 Washington Submit Aside from her signature on it, this transfer in opposition to the integrity of the court docket itself by means of juror quantity 15 is a brand new discovered high-risk technique.

“The knowledge on the juror listing doesn’t seem to match the id and demographics of one of many jurors,” the memo, signed by Bredehoft, stated. “Juror #15 seems to have been born in 1970 and never 1945 as reported and referred to by the events, together with Ms Hurd, within the choice of the jury,” the doc continues.

“Given the verification necessities of every juror, it seems that the id of the juror has not been verified,” he provides damningly of the Previous Dominion trial. “It’s unclear whether or not Juror #15 was ever referred to as to serve on a jury or whether or not he was certified to serve on the bench. This requires an investigation by this court docket to find out whether or not a jury was truly referred to as and whether or not the due course of rights of the events had been violated. Relying on the outcomes of the investigation, this may increasingly function a foundation for canceling the decision as a complete and sending the case for a brand new trial.”

After an obvious six-week trial, a seven-member jury awarded Depp $10 million in damages and $5 million in punitive damages, the latter of which was lowered to $350,000 on account of a Virginia statutory ceiling. Echoing statements made by Heard and her legal professionals after the conclusion of the trial, a brand new temporary dated July 1 states that “the decision is extreme as a matter of regulation within the mild of the proof and the regulation and have to be overturned.”

“Proof as soon as once more of the confusion ensuing from Mr. Depp’s makes an attempt to reopen the 2016 household relationship case with out confirming the constancy of the UK resolution, the jury’s verdicts within the duel are inconsistent and intransigent,” the memo reads, specializing in each the unstable couple, a brief restraining order is punctuated by a divorce. He additionally provides a little bit of salt by highlighting Depp’s loss throughout the Atlantic on the finish of 2020 in his libel lawsuit in opposition to Rupert Murdoch. Solar tabloid for calling him a “spouse beater”.

“The defamation discovering in opposition to Ms. Heard with $2 million in damages is inconsistent with the libel discovering in opposition to Mr. Depp with a $15 million award,” the paperwork notice in what many thought of a thriller of the counterclaim resolution. Hurd’s 2020 lawsuit. .

Whereas the article written by the ACLU is usually in a newspaper owned by Jeff Bezos, Vapo With out truly ever mentioning Depp by identify, the wrangler claimed it “devastated” his already waning profession. In court docket paperwork and on the stand, Depp went on to say that he was, actually, the one who was abused within the relationship.

Not often mentioning the First Modification earlier than closing arguments, Hurd’s crew is now specializing in the scope and depth required to convey a defamation go well with, as Depp has performed to date. The earlier Oscar nominee and his Brown Rudnick LLP crew didn’t meet the usual:

For the jury to conclude that Ms. Heard demonstrated actual malice, Mr. Depp needed to show on the time of posting the remark that Ms. Heard didn’t imagine she had been abused, or that she had doubts about whether or not she was abused. However Mr. Depp provided no proof that Ms. Hurd didn’t imagine she had been abused. As an alternative, the proof overwhelmingly supported that Ms. Hurd believed she was the sufferer of Mr. Depp’s abuse. Thus, Mr. Depp didn’t meet the necessities of the particular malice regulation, and the sentence ought to be overturned.

Representatives for Depp and his authorized crew, led by Ben Chu and Camilla Vasquez, didn’t reply to a request for remark immediately on Heard’s new movement and accompanying notice. Then again, Hollywood Vampires guitarist Depp himself, who made a number of appearances on stage with Jeff Beck within the UK final month throughout and after jury deliberations, did take to social media this weekend. Exhibiting a bit much less swagger than he is been on-line within the hours and day instantly after the defamation verdict, Depp hasn’t acquired any direct response to the brand new lawsuit both – to date:

About the author


Leave a Comment

%d bloggers like this: